Vinyl vs Hardie Fiber-Cement Board Siding: Which is Right for You?

Written by Michael Myers

January 29, 2024

 

Choosing the right siding for your home is not an easy decision. There are a lot of factors to consider, such as cost, durability, and aesthetics.

Two popular siding options that homeowners often compare are vinyl and Hardie fiber-cement board.

This blog post will compare these two materials and help you decide which is suitable for your home.

Durability:

Regarding durability, both vinyl and Hardie fiber-cement board have their strengths. Vinyl siding is known for its resistance to moisture and insects, and it can last up to 25 years or more if installed correctly.

Hardie fiber-cement board, on the other hand, is resistant to fire, moisture, and insects and can last up to 50 years or more.

However, Hardie fiber-cement board is more susceptible to damage from impact, such as hail or wind-blown debris.

Vinyl siding, while also not wholly impervious to damage, can handle these types of impacts better.

Cost:

Cost is always a factor when it comes to home improvements. Vinyl siding is typically less expensive to install than Hardie fiber-cement board. However, its longer lifespan can offset the cost of Hardie fiber-cement board.

Hardie fiber-cement board is often viewed as a premium siding material, adding more resale value to a home.

james hardie siding 5

Maintenance:

Vinyl siding requires little maintenance and can be cleaned with a power washer or a mild soap solution.

Hardie fiber-cement board is more resilient to weather and insects but still requires periodic washing and inspection to ensure it stays in good condition.

Additionally, if any repairs are needed, Hardie fiber-cement board requires a professional installation, while a skilled DIYer can replace vinyl siding.

Aesthetics:

Both vinyl siding and Hardie fiber-cement board offer various aesthetic options to compliment the style of any home.

Vinyl siding is available in various colors and textures, from smooth and sleek to grainy wood-like finishes. The hardie fiber-cement board offers authentic wood-like textures with the added durability of cement board.

Additionally, it can be painted any color, providing almost endless design possibilities. Ultimately, which one you choose will depend on your personal preferences and the style of your home.

Conclusion:

Deciding between vinyl and Hardie fiber-cement board siding can be a tough decision. With both materials offering their benefits, it’s essential to prioritize what’s most important to you. Hardie fiber-cement board may be the best option if durability is your top priority.

However, if cost and ease of maintenance are essential to you, vinyl siding may be the way to go. Ultimately, the choice between the two comes down to a matter of personal preference and the specific needs of your home. Whichever option you choose, do your research and work with a trusted professional for the best results.

 

You may also like to take a look at some of these great resources:

Also, here are some resources to help you select a reputable contractor: